The iPhone 4S has been out three months now (has it only been that long?) and I’m still seeing and hearing questions from individuals whether they should upgrade to the iPhone 4S from an older version of the iPhone. Or even from Android. A lot of questions I see are regarding whether Siri represents enough of a feature update that would coax individuals to upgrade their current phone to the iPhone 4S. Siri is one of the features that I was most interested in, and which caused me to jump ship from Android (HTC EVO). But now that I’ve had ample opportunity to use Siri I’d have to say that if it’s the single feature you’re focusing on, you probably won’t be completely happy with it.
Believe it or not, Siri is still a beta technology. And even though my personal experience with Siri has been fairly happy, the commercials where Siri are demonstrated are a tad misleading. Siri is a fun technology and can be a wonderful help, but it clearly hasn’t grown into its full potential as of yet and its unknown when it might do so. That being said, the iPhone 4s, along with iOS 5.x, offer an incredibly polished experience. One that I’m completely happy I’ve now gotten to experience myself. In my view, if you currently own an iPhone 4 it probably isn’t worthwhile to upgrade to the 4S. Both iPhone 4 and iPhone 4S are 3G phones, unless you’re an AT&T customer. The AT&T iPhone 4S is capable of generally higher speeds over AT&T’s HSPA+ network, so even officially an 3G phone, you come the closest to the 4G experience with AT&T.
Outside of that, the iPhone 4 and iPhone 4S experience are similar. There were not a tremendous number of feature additions between the two models. But if you have an older iPhone, or if you’re not an iPhone owner at all it might be worthwhile to upgrade. At the end of the day individuals will have to look closely at the hardware and the operating system and make a decision which best suits their needs and desires. Don’t focus on any one feature, but look at the handset and the user experience as a whole. In my case the terrible power management issues I was experiencing on my HTC EVO and my general disdain for the lack of operating systems updates from my carrier provided me the incentive I needed to jump ship. But now that I have I can honestly say I’m nothing but happy that I did, and Siri alone ended up being a very small part of the reason.








